Wed 15 May 2013 6pm
in the Vienna Konzerthaus, Lothringerstraße 20, 1030 Vienna, Austria
Wiener Symphoniker
Harke de Roos
A new way to Beethoven with live music and moderation by
Michael Haas, Harke de Roos, Richard Winter
We kindly ask for seat-reservation!
klassik@gramola.at; Tel.: 01-505 38 01
Extraordinary stories do not happen every day, either in daily life, or in music. You would expect them least of all in the symphonic oeuvre of Ludwig van Beethoven, where every note has been played, described and analyzed countless times.
All the more astonishing is Harke de Roos with his interpretation of Beethoven’s 2nd Symphony, performed by the Vienna Symphony Orchestra. The Dutch musician, music researcher and music author claims to have found a completely new approach to Beethoven, not only to his music, but also to his personality. According to his research, Beethoven’s music is based on the tempo structure of Viennese Classicism, which perished during the Romantic period and has never returned to the performance practice of classical music. This tempo structure is characterized by organic connections between the movements of each classical composition. In origin, all tempi had a very close relationship to one other like the members of a family. Over the years, they became more and more independent and their family relationship receded. At the same time, tempo contrasts increased and a gap arose in the centre of the tempo ladder. The broad spectrum of terms like ‘adagio’ and ‘allegro’ narrowed down to one-sided concepts such as ‘slow’ and ‘fast’.
This development of the performance practice of Viennese Classicism is only one part of the story. The other part concerns the correct reading of Beethoven’s own notation. Since 1817, there has been a list of single-handed metronome indications for the central section of Beethoven’s oeuvre, including the symphonies. It is common knowledge that these indications have led to controversies in the professional world because of extreme tempi and impossible note values. First of all, it is amazing that there is not the slightest trace of the organic relationship which must have existed between the original tempi. What has happened to the tempo family? Where has it gone?
The answer found by Harke de Roos is disturbingly simple. The prosaic metronome numbers do not constitute a technical user manual, but have to be read as a personal message by the composer. The indications have the form of an enigma and are related to the riddle canons of Bach, Mozart and Beethoven himself. The message behind the numbers is related to every interpreter personally and is in no way affected by Beethoven’s death. So the composer appears to anyone willing to listen to what the message says. Listening to the words behind the message, you will experience Beethoven as vividly as the spirit of Hamlet’s father or Mozart’s Commendatore.
What do the words tell you? The first statement is: I need you! Moreover: I need you personally! I need you to recognize the brokenness of my tempi. I need you to realize the insight that these broken tempi express my own brokenness. I need you to repair the ruptures in my life. I need you to heal me. I give you responsibility for my health. As a creative partner, I give you equal rights. So, on the one hand, Beethoven's tempo indications are an intellectual musical game and an act of despair, on the other.
Viewed in this light, the first recording of a symphony by Beethoven with repaired tempo relations is part of a great story. Nonetheless, the reactions of the professional world to this story are themselves parts of the whole story. How did the musical scene in Holland react, how did the one in Germany? How did great conductors respond, how did the ‘Beethovenhaus’ in Bonn?
It is evident that the Vienna Symphony Orchestra has reacted in an exemplary manner. The members of this long-standing orchestra did not argue for one moment, but simply performed the music. There are no better arguments!
In Winter's House Christmas with...
Vilém Veverka: Christmas Album
Matthias Well & Lilian Akopova
The Sixteen & Harry Christophers
Salzburger Festspiele 2021:...
Nabucco: Oper im Steinbruch 2022
Kaleidoscope Chamber Collective
Osterfestspiele 2021: Auszüge...
Leonard Bernstein: Sämtliche...
Viktoria Mullova & Alasdair...
Martha Argerich & Sophie Pacini
Vera Karner & Andres Anazco:...
Andreas Gilger: Dessiner les...
André Heller: Der Rosenkavalier
Richard Flury: Die helle Nacht
Marin Alsop & Garnett Bruce:...
Alois J. Hochstrasser: eine...
Somar Ajalyaqin: Contemplations
Benjamin Britten: The Turn of...
ARC Ensemble: Dimitri Klebanov
Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau: Frühe...
I Puritani mit Brownlee & Coburn
Daniel Barenboim or the Power of...
Gordon Sherwood: Complete Songs...
Fauré: Die Gesamten Lieder Vol....
Jordi Savall: Zum 80. Geburtstag
Sreten Krstic & Ludwig Schmitt
Louise Chisson & Tamara Atschba
Romantische Klavierkonzerte Vol....
Veronika Skuplik & Jörg Jacobi
Exhibition on Screen: Frida...
Sergei Rachmaninov: Sinfonie Nr....
HK Gruber: Percussion Concertos
John Thomas: Complete Duos for...
Andrea Battistoni & das Tokyo...
Große Opernabende aus der Wiener...
Ungarische Tänze für Cello und...
International Classical Music...
Harnoncourts revolutionärer...
Anton Bruckner: Die Sinfonien -...
Bruckner Society of America:...
Konstantin Reymaier: The New...
Sir Simon Rattle dirigiert: Das...
Membran: Große Werke & berühmte...
St. Johns College Cambridge &...
Ernst Krenek: Klaviermusik Vol.2
Erik Satie: Klavierwerke Vol. 7
The Cleveland Orchestra: A new...
In Gedenken an den Künstler...
John Williams Live in Vienna:...
Supersonic: Dvorak Klaviertrios
Das Schönste aus der Welt der...
James MacMillan: Sinfonie 5 &...
Rudolf Buchbinder: The Diabelli...
Die romantischen Klavierkonzerte
In Memoriam: Paul Badura-Skoda
Heinz Winbeck: Die gesamten...
Die Bassariden | Salzburger...
Deutsche Streicherphilharmonie
Die Zauberflöte - Salzburg 1982
Philippe Jordan: Tchaikovsky...
Festkonzert zum 90. Geburtstag
Henry Raudales & das Münchner...
Ballettmusik mit Mariss Jansons
Naxos-Neuheiten September 2018
Leonard Bernstein: Zum 100....
Karlheinz Stockhausen - 90....
Dmitri Hvorostovsky - Live in...
Salzburger Festspieleröffnungen...
Nabucco aus der Arena di Verona
Lucia di Lammermoor mit Editha...
Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg...
Bregenzer Festspiele 2017: Moses...
Birgit Nilsson: A League of her...
Tristan und Isolde mit Birgit...
Ö1-Pasticciopreis für "Rejoice"
NIJINSKY - A Ballet by John...
Anthology of Russian Symphonic...
Daniel Behle in Cosi fan tutte
Magic Moments of Music: Maria...
Das ORF Radio-Symphonieorchester...
Antonio Rosetti: Sinfonien &...
Gottfried von Einem: Der Besuch...
Three Billboards Outside Ebbing,...
Das RCO & Mariss Jansons: Mahler...
James Gilchrist & Anna Tilbrook
Pique Dame | Royal Concertgebouw...
Naxos Bestseller Dezember 2018
Johann Strauss and the Tradition...
Die Glocken & Symphonische Tänze
Il Prigionero aus der Opern in...
Die Walküre - Osterfestpiele...
Brahms Lieder mit Grace Bumbry
J. S. Bach: Weihnachtsoratorium
Wladimir Dawidowitsch Aschkenasi
Naxos Neuheiten September 2017
Georg Friedrich Händel: The...
Capriccio Barockorchester Basel
Bruckner mit Franz Welser-Möst
30 Jahre Naxos-Jubiläumsedition
Gardiner dirigiert Mendelssohn
Das Liebesverbot von Richard...
Herbert Kefer - Konzerte für...
Simon Schembri / Quatuor Parisii
Rémy Ballot dirigiert Bruckner
Weihnachtliche Neuerscheinungen
Gramola Weihnachtsempfehlungen...
In Memoriam Sir Neville Marriner
Rachmaninov-Zyklus mit Gergiev
Da Ponte Operas mit Nikolaus...
Erik Satie zum 150. Geburtstag
Zum 125. Geburtstag von Sergej...
Les Contes d'Hoffmann/Bregenz...
In Gedenken an Sir Peter Maxwell...
John Neumeiers Matthäus Passion
Der Freischütz/Semperoper 2015
Echo Klassik für "Rosenkavalier"
Lorin Maazel / Philharmonia...
Paul McCreesh / Gabrieli Consort
Thielemanns Ring des Nibelungen
300. Geburtstag von C.P.E. Bach